Labyrinth, Inc. LogoLabyrinth, Inc. LogoLabyrinth, Inc. LogoLabyrinth, Inc. Logo
  • Our Services
    • Fundraising Registration
      • Charitable Registration
      • Charitable Registered Agent
      • Dynamic Disclosures
      • Fundraiser Registration
    • Secretary of State
      • Amendment
      • Annual Reports
      • Dissolution and Withdrawal
      • Foreign Qualification
      • Initial Report
      • Name Reservation
      • Nonprofit Formation
      • Publishing
      • Registered Agent
    • Tax Registration and Exemption
      • Payroll Tax Registration
      • Sales and Use Tax Registration
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Careers
    • Partnerships
      • Content Partnerships
      • Referral Partnerships
    • Client Testimonials
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Information Center
    • Webinar
    • State by State Compliance Guide
    • White Papers
      • Charitable Registration White Paper
  • Contact Us
    • 888-532-0723
  • Lock IconLOGIN

Donor Privacy Is At Stake

  • Home
  • Nonprofit Resources
  • Blog
  • Uncategorized
  • Donor Privacy Is At Stake
Paycheck Protection Program
Second Paycheck Protection Program for Nonprofit Organizations
January 27, 2021
This complete guide dives into common nonprofit state filing requirements.
Nonprofit State Filing Requirements: Complete Overview
March 9, 2021
February 4, 2021
Categories
  • Uncategorized
Tags
donor privacy donor disclosure

Could Your Nonprofit Be Forced to Disclose the Identities Of Its Donors?

The Supreme Court Will Hear the Donor Privacy Case Against the State of California

Question Before the Supreme Court 

“Does California’s requirement that charitable organizations that fundraise in the state disclose to the state Attorney General’s office the identities of their substantial contributors violate the constitutional freedom of association.”

Donor Privacy

For decades, the issue of donor privacy has enjoyed a widespread consensus. However, in recent years some states have begun mandating the disclosure of donor information contained in the 990 Schedule B. In addition, the 2010 US Supreme Court decision in Citizen’s United v. Federal Election Commission, which allowed incorporated entities, unions, and other organizations to expressly advocate for the election or defeat of candidates for office, has prompted calls from some for greater transparency in political spending.

On March 8, 2019, the US House of Representatives passed and anti-corruption bill – H.R. 1— For the People Act that includes language from the Disclose Act, which requires certain nonprofit organization to make public its lists of donors who contribute $10,000 or more. If that were to eventually pass in the Senate, it could be signed into law by the current administration.

While the confidentiality of donations to 501(c)(3) organizations remains largely protected at the federal level, a number of states are introducing legislation to mandate 501(c)(3) organizations to disclose the names of some and, in some instances, all of their donors. In 2019, for example, Idaho legislators introduced Bill S.1114, that would have required a nonprofit that merely mentions a candidate by name in one of its communications to disclose its donors.

To date in February, 2021, 15 states have considered donor-disclosure bills that would mandate disclosure. They have either been abandoned after opposition, or struck down by the courts. So far, only four of these bills remain active. Due to its outsize role, the most notable of the lawsuits is the two donor privacy challenges to California’s compulsory donor disclosure for nonprofit organizations. They are: Americans for Prosperity Foundation v. Becerra (Case No. 19-251) and, the Thomas More Society v. Xavier Becerra (Case No. 19-255). The Americans for Prosperity Foundation prevailed in district court only for the decision to be overturned by the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

A Supreme Court Ruling On Donor Disclosure

The US Supreme Court granted certiorari, in other words, accepting to hear the donor privacy cases against AG Xavier Becerra (pending senate confirmation, Xavier Becerra has been nominated to lead the Human & Health Services). The issue thus far has been the lack of uniformity in the lower courts in the jurisprudence of First Amendment privacy and in judicial outcomes. The ruling in the Supreme Court will answer or put to rest the question whether compelled disclosure violates the First Amendment. The Supreme Court decision should identify categories of speech and association and then instruct the lower courts on which subjects or categories of speech and association are subject to overriding governmental interests, such as in the case against California Attorney General Xavier Becerra. Given its outsized role, the decision of the Supreme Court will not only affect California residents, but also any nonprofit that solicits donations in California, the nation’s most populous state.

What Donor Disclosure Could Mean For Your Nonprofit

While it is important for nonprofit organizations to not abuse their tax-exempt status and to be subject to oversight, donors have important reasons to keep their charitable contributions anonymous. Some of the reasons could be to avoid public scrutiny, to minimize possible solicitations from other charitable organizations, or simply for the sake of humility.

Donor privacy is a very important policy for nonprofit organizations as it facilitates donations to causes that could be deemed controversial. Donors to such causes can donate freely without the fear of reprisal. There is no telling how a Supreme Court ruling in favor of Attorney General Becerra might impact donor engagement.

Share

Related posts

August 5, 2022

State Agencies Experience Ongoing Filing Delays


Read more
July 26, 2022

California Temporarily Waives Filing Fees for Nonprofits, Corporations, LLCs, and Others


Read more
Upcoming Form 990 Filing Deadlines
May 23, 2022

Upcoming Form 990 Filing Deadlines


Read more

Stay Informed

Get our sector insights, research, and educational content first!

Sign Up For Emails

logo Inc.5000Labyrinth

Company

  • About Us
  • FAQs
  • Resources
  • Help Center
  • Client Testimonials
  • Careers

Services

  • Charity Registration
  • Fundraiser Registration
  • Registered Agents
  • Annual Reports
  • Foreign Qualification
Contact Us
  • 888-532-0723
  • info@labyrinthinc.com

We proudly provide compliance services for:


Labyrinth Inc. does not provide tax, financial, or legal advice. Use of our services does not create an attorney-client relationship. Labyrinth is not acting as your attorney and does not review information you provide to us for legal accuracy or sufficiency. Access to our website is subject to our Terms of Use and Service Agreement.

Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Secure Shopping
© 2023 Labyrinth, Inc. All Rights Reserved.